Why Did Joseph Practice Divination with a Silver Cup?

Introduction

The question, “Why did Joseph practice divination with a silver cup?” refers to a perplexing episode in Genesis 44, where Joseph’s brothers are accused of stealing his silver cup, which he claimed to use for divination. This incident raises questions about Joseph’s character and the meaning of divination in the biblical context. Understanding this passage requires examining the historical and cultural background, the literary context of the story, and Joseph’s broader purpose in using the cup as part of his dealings with his brothers. Ultimately, this account reflects a strategic move by Joseph rather than an endorsement of divination practices, as he sought to test his brothers’ integrity and repentance.

Narrative Context

In Genesis 44, Joseph, now a powerful official in Egypt, secretly places his silver cup in the sack of his youngest brother, Benjamin. After the brothers leave, Joseph’s steward pursues them and accuses them of theft. When the cup is found in Benjamin’s sack, the brothers are brought back to Joseph. He then states, “Don’t you know that such a man as I can indeed practice divination?” (Genesis 44:15 WEB).

The historical and cultural context is crucial here. In ancient Egypt, divination was a common practice among officials and priests, used to seek guidance from the gods regarding future events or decisions. This context helps us understand why Joseph, as an Egyptian official, might refer to the practice. However, throughout the story, there is no indication that Joseph actually practiced divination. Instead, his mention of the cup is part of a larger scheme to test his brothers’ character and determine whether they had changed since they sold him into slavery years earlier.

Scriptural Foundations

Several key verses from the World English Bible (WEB) provide insight into this narrative and its implications:

Genesis 44:2 (WEB):
“He commanded the steward of his house, saying, ‘Fill the men’s sacks with food, as much as they can carry, and put each man’s money in his sack’s mouth. Put my cup, the silver cup, in the sack’s mouth of the youngest, with his grain money.’ He did according to the word that Joseph had spoken.”

Explanation:
Joseph orchestrates the placement of the silver cup in Benjamin’s sack, setting the stage for the confrontation that follows. This act is not about divination but about creating a situation that will test his brothers’ loyalty to Benjamin and their willingness to protect him.

Genesis 44:5 (WEB):
“Isn’t this that from which my lord drinks, and by which he indeed divines? You have done evil in so doing.'”

Explanation:
The steward’s statement reinforces the pretense that the cup is used for divination. However, this does not necessarily mean that Joseph actually practiced divination. It is part of the ruse to heighten the stakes of the situation and to evoke a response from the brothers, particularly in terms of their concern for Benjamin’s fate.

Genesis 44:16 (WEB):
“Judah said, ‘What will we tell my lord? What will we speak? Or how will we clear ourselves? God has found out the iniquity of your servants. Behold, we are my lord’s slaves, both we and he also in whose hand the cup is found.'”

Explanation:
Judah’s response reveals the brothers’ transformation. They do not abandon Benjamin but instead take collective responsibility, showing a deep sense of remorse and unity that contrasts with their previous betrayal of Joseph.

Perspectives from Others

1. Testing the Brothers’ Integrity:
   Many scholars believe that Joseph’s actions, including the use of the silver cup, were intended to test his brothers’ integrity and repentance. By accusing them of stealing the cup, he recreated a scenario in which his brothers had to choose between self-preservation and loyalty to their youngest brother, Benjamin. This test ultimately demonstrated that they had changed since the time they sold Joseph into slavery.
2. Symbolic Use of the Cup:
   Some interpreters see the silver cup as a symbol of authority and discernment rather than a literal tool for divination. Joseph, as a ruler in Egypt, used this symbol to emphasize his power and knowledge, which the brothers would have perceived as almost supernatural. This perception increased the drama of the situation and tested their honesty and fear of God.
3. Cultural Accommodation:
   Another view is that Joseph’s reference to divination was a form of cultural accommodation. As an Egyptian official, he maintained appearances that aligned with Egyptian customs, even if he did not personally engage in such practices. This strategy would have helped maintain his authority and position while he maneuvered to reunite with his family.

Identifying Misunderstandings

One common misconception is that Joseph, a man of God, actually practiced divination. However, the narrative does not support this interpretation. The use of the silver cup was part of a calculated strategy to test his brothers, not an endorsement of divination. In fact, the Bible consistently condemns divination and other forms of occult practices (Leviticus 19:26, Deuteronomy 18:10-12), which suggests that Joseph’s actions were not meant to condone such practices but to achieve a specific purpose.

Another misunderstanding is that this incident was purely about punishment or revenge. Joseph’s ultimate goal was reconciliation with his family. The silver cup incident was a crucial part of revealing his brothers’ changed hearts and bringing about healing for their past sins against him.

Relevance and Application for You

Joseph’s use of the silver cup in this narrative offers several lessons for modern believers:

1. Discernment in Testing Others:
   Joseph’s actions demonstrate the importance of discernment and wisdom in testing the motives and character of others. While we should not deceive or manipulate, there are times when it is appropriate to carefully assess someone’s integrity before entrusting them with responsibilities or forgiveness.
2. The Power of Forgiveness and Reconciliation:
   Joseph’s ultimate aim was not to harm his brothers but to bring about true repentance and reconciliation. This story challenges us to seek healing and restoration in our relationships, even when it requires confronting painful truths.
3. God’s Sovereignty in Difficult Situations:
   Joseph’s life, including this episode, is a testimony to God’s sovereignty. What seemed like a bizarre or harsh test was part of God’s plan to preserve Jacob’s family and fulfill His promises to Abraham. We are reminded to trust God’s purposes, even when we do not fully understand His ways.

Encouragement and Conclusion

The story of Joseph and the silver cup is not about endorsing divination but about testing and revealing the hearts of his brothers. It shows us that God can use complex and even confusing situations to accomplish His purposes of reconciliation and restoration. As we seek to love what God loves—truth, integrity, and forgiveness—and to hate what He hates—deception, injustice, and division—may we be inspired by Joseph’s example to seek wisdom, discernment, and reconciliation in all our relationships. Let us trust that God, who worked through Joseph’s life to preserve and bless His people, is also at work in our lives, using every situation for His greater glory and our ultimate good.