Were the Apostles Levi (Matthew) and James Brothers?

Introduction

The question, “Were the apostles Levi (Matthew) and James brothers?” invites an exploration into the familial relationships among Jesus’ apostles, specifically focusing on Levi (also known as Matthew) and James. Understanding these relationships provides insights into the early Christian community and the dynamics among those who followed Jesus. While both Levi (Matthew) and James were among the twelve apostles chosen by Jesus, examining the biblical texts reveals whether they were biological brothers or shared only a spiritual bond as disciples of Christ.

Narrative Context

Levi, also known as Matthew, and James are two distinct apostles mentioned in the Gospels. Levi was a tax collector called by Jesus to follow Him (Mark 2:14). His calling is significant, given that tax collectors were generally despised in Jewish society for collaborating with the Roman authorities. Levi’s willingness to leave his lucrative and controversial profession to follow Jesus speaks volumes about his transformation and commitment.

James, often referred to as “James, son of Alphaeus,” is one of the less detailed apostles in the New Testament. He is sometimes identified as James the Less to distinguish him from James, the son of Zebedee, another apostle. James, the son of Alphaeus, is often considered one of the “minor apostles” due to the limited information provided about him. The phrase “James the Less” (Mark 15:40) may refer to his stature or younger age compared to James, the son of Zebedee.

The Gospels do not explicitly state that Levi (Matthew) and James were brothers, but both are listed among the twelve apostles. Understanding the context of their callings and the different ways they are mentioned in the Gospels helps clarify their relationship.

Scriptural Foundations

Several key verses from the World English Bible (WEB) provide insight into the identities of Levi and James and their relationship as apostles:

Mark 2:14: “As he passed by, he saw Levi, the son of Alphaeus, sitting at the tax office, and he said to him, ‘Follow me.’ And he arose and followed him.”

This verse identifies Levi, also known as Matthew, as the “son of Alphaeus.” It records Jesus’ calling of Levi from his position as a tax collector to become one of His disciples.

Mark 3:18: “Andrew, Philip, Bartholomew, Matthew, Thomas, James the son of Alphaeus, Thaddaeus, Simon the Zealot.”

Here, Levi is referred to as “Matthew,” and James is called “James, the son of Alphaeus.” This has led to some debate since both are described as sons of Alphaeus, suggesting a possible familial relationship.

Matthew 10:3: “Philip, Bartholomew, Thomas, and Matthew the tax collector; James the son of Alphaeus, and Thaddaeus.”

Matthew is mentioned separately from James, son of Alphaeus, indicating they are different individuals. If they were brothers, we might expect a direct mention, as is the case with James and John, the sons of Zebedee, who are often listed together.

Perspectives from Others

Some biblical scholars suggest that because both Levi (Matthew) and James are referred to as “sons of Alphaeus,” they might indeed be brothers. This interpretation hinges on the assumption that “Alphaeus” is the same individual for both apostles, although this is not explicitly stated in Scripture. This viewpoint sees a familial connection as likely but not definitively confirmed.

Other scholars argue that the Gospels are silent on the specific familial relationship between Levi and James, and the shared name “Alphaeus” could refer to two different men. The lack of additional supporting details about their relationship as brothers, like the narrative provided for James and John, weakens the argument for their brotherhood.

The perspective most aligned with biblical teachings is one that acknowledges the ambiguity surrounding this question. While Levi and James are both “sons of Alphaeus,” the biblical text does not provide enough evidence to confirm they were brothers. Therefore, it is most prudent to conclude that they may have shared a spiritual kinship as apostles rather than a confirmed biological relationship.

Identifying Misunderstandings

A common misunderstanding is assuming that because Levi and James are both called “sons of Alphaeus,” they must be biological brothers. However, “Alphaeus” was a common name during that period, and there is no clear biblical statement that explicitly identifies them as brothers.

Another misconception is that every apostle with the same family name was necessarily related. The New Testament’s primary focus is on spiritual kinship in Christ rather than biological relationships. Emphasizing spiritual bonds over potential familial ties is more consistent with the overarching message of the Gospels.

Relevance and Application for You

For modern Christians, the discussion of whether Levi and James were brothers can serve as a reminder of the unity that believers share in Christ. While biological relationships are significant, the spiritual kinship we have as members of the body of Christ is more crucial. This understanding encourages believers to focus on loving one another as brothers and sisters in Christ, regardless of earthly ties.

Furthermore, the ambiguity of Levi and James’s relationship invites us to embrace the mystery and diversity within the body of Christ. Rather than focusing on what is uncertain, Christians are encouraged to celebrate the unity we have through our shared faith and commitment to follow Jesus, just as Levi and James did.

Encouragement and Conclusion

While the Bible does not definitively state whether Levi (Matthew) and James were biological brothers, what is clear is that they were both chosen by Jesus to be His apostles and to spread the Gospel. This shared calling is a powerful testament to the spiritual family that Jesus established among His followers. As believers, we are called to love and support one another as members of God’s family, focusing on what unites us rather than what divides us. Let us be encouraged to embrace our spiritual kinship, recognizing that in Christ, we are all brothers and sisters, anointed to share His love and truth with the world.