Should We Be Casting Lots to Choose Church Leaders Today?

Introduction

The question, “Should we be casting lots to choose church leaders today?” addresses an ancient practice used in biblical times to make decisions and discern God’s will. The practice of casting lots, similar to drawing straws or rolling dice, was used in both the Old and New Testaments for various purposes, including selecting leaders. With the appointment of Matthias to replace Judas as an apostle being the most notable New Testament example (Acts 1:26), some may wonder if this method should still be used in church leadership decisions today. To answer this question comprehensively, we will explore the historical and biblical context of casting lots, its significance, and the principles for selecting leaders in the church today according to Scripture.

Narrative Context

Casting lots was a common practice in ancient cultures, including among the Israelites, to make decisions or determine God’s will when no clear direction was apparent. In the Old Testament, lots were used to distribute land among the tribes of Israel (Joshua 18:6) and to identify Achan as the guilty party when Israel was defeated at Ai (Joshua 7:14-18). It was a way of seeking divine guidance in situations where human judgment might be insufficient or biased.

In the New Testament, the most prominent instance of casting lots occurs in Acts 1:24-26, where the apostles used this method to select Matthias as the replacement for Judas Iscariot. This event took place before the outpouring of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost, indicating a transitional period in the early church. After the Holy Spirit was given, we see no further mention of casting lots in decision-making, suggesting a shift in how the early church discerned God’s will.

Scriptural Foundations

Several key verses from the World English Bible (WEB) provide insight into the practice of casting lots and its role in biblical decision-making:

Proverbs 16:33: “The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from Yahweh.”

This verse reflects the belief that, although casting lots may seem random, God is ultimately in control of the outcome. It emphasizes the sovereignty of God in guiding decisions made through this method.

Acts 1:24-26: “They prayed and said, ‘You, Lord, who know the hearts of all men, show which one of these two you have chosen to take part in this ministry and apostleship from which Judas fell away, that he might go to his own place.’ They cast lots for them, and the lot fell on Matthias, and he was counted with the eleven apostles.”

The apostles sought God’s guidance through prayer before casting lots. This shows their reliance on God’s sovereignty but also highlights that this practice was used before the Holy Spirit was given at Pentecost.

1 Timothy 3:1-2: “This is a faithful saying: someone who seeks to be an overseer desires a good work. The overseer must be without reproach, the husband of one wife, temperate, sensible, modest, hospitable, good at teaching.”

Paul’s instructions to Timothy on the qualifications for church leaders emphasize character, integrity, and spiritual maturity rather than relying on a method like casting lots. This indicates a shift in how church leadership was to be discerned.

Perspectives from Others

Some interpret the use of casting lots in Acts 1 as a valid method for decision-making in the church today, arguing that it demonstrates reliance on God’s sovereignty. They suggest that in situations where human judgment is uncertain or prone to bias, casting lots could be used to seek God’s guidance.

However, most scholars and theologians believe that the use of casting lots was specific to the pre-Pentecost period. They argue that after the Holy Spirit was given, the early church relied on the Spirit’s guidance through prayer, discernment, and the collective wisdom of the church community. This view is supported by the New Testament epistles, which outline qualifications and processes for selecting church leaders based on spiritual maturity and character rather than random selection.

The perspective most aligned with biblical teachings suggests that while casting lots was a legitimate method before the Holy Spirit was given, it is no longer necessary or advisable for selecting church leaders today. Instead, the focus should be on prayerful discernment, seeking the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and evaluating candidates based on biblical qualifications.

Identifying Misunderstandings

A common misunderstanding is that casting lots is a form of gambling or chance, and using it to make decisions lacks faith. However, in biblical times, casting lots was seen as a means of submitting to God’s will, trusting that He would direct the outcome.

Another misconception is that the Bible mandates casting lots for decision-making in all situations. While it was used in specific contexts, the New Testament provides other methods for discerning God’s will, such as prayer, seeking the Holy Spirit’s guidance, and evaluating individuals based on their character and spiritual maturity.

Relevance and Application for You

For modern Christians and church communities, selecting leaders is a matter of serious prayer and discernment. Instead of casting lots, which may feel arbitrary or outdated, the focus should be on seeking the Holy Spirit’s guidance through prayer and evaluating candidates based on the qualifications outlined in Scripture.

1. Prayerful Discernment: The first step in choosing church leaders should always be prayer. Seeking God’s will together as a community and being open to the Holy Spirit’s leading is crucial.
2. Biblical Qualifications: Church leaders should be evaluated based on the qualifications given in passages like 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1. These include integrity, spiritual maturity, and a strong reputation within the church and community.
3. Community Involvement: Involving the church community in the selection process helps ensure that decisions are made with wisdom, humility, and accountability, reflecting the collective discernment of God’s people.

Encouragement and Conclusion

While the practice of casting lots was used in biblical times, the New Testament provides a fuller revelation of how to seek God’s will through the Holy Spirit’s guidance and the discernment of the church community. As we choose leaders today, let us focus on prayer, biblical qualifications, and the wisdom of the Spirit, trusting that God will guide us as we seek to honor Him in all that we do. By doing so, we can love what God loves—wisdom, integrity, and spiritual maturity—and avoid actions that may lead to division or confusion. Let us be encouraged to seek God’s will with open hearts and minds, knowing that He is faithful to guide His people in every decision.