The F.O.G Commentary:
What is the meaning of 1 Samuel 10?
Introduction to 1 Samuel 10
1 Samuel 10 marks a pivotal moment in Israel’s history as Samuel anoints Saul as the first king of Israel. This chapter serves as a bridge between the period of the judges and the monarchical period, showcasing both God’s accommodation of Israel’s desire for a king and His sovereign oversight in the selection process. The narrative provides a fascinating glimpse into ancient anointing ceremonies, prophetic confirmation, and the complex dynamics of leadership transition in ancient Israel.
The significance of this chapter extends beyond mere historical record, as it demonstrates God’s intricate involvement in human affairs and His ability to work through both ideal and less-than-ideal circumstances to accomplish His purposes. Through supernatural signs, prophetic utterances, and divine orchestration, we witness the emergence of Israel’s monarchy within God’s redemptive plan.
Context of 1 Samuel 10
This chapter follows directly from Samuel’s private encounter with Saul in chapter 9, where God revealed to Samuel that the tall young man searching for his father’s donkeys would become Israel’s first king. The immediate context shows God’s response to Israel’s demand for a king “like all the nations” (1 Samuel 8:5), despite Samuel’s warnings about the consequences of monarchical rule.
Within the broader narrative of 1 Samuel, this chapter represents a crucial transition point. It bridges the gap between the period of the judges, where God ruled directly through charismatic leaders, and the monarchical period, where human kings would govern under divine sovereignty. This shift carries profound implications for Israel’s relationship with יהוה (Yahweh) and their identity as His chosen people.
In the larger context of Scripture, 1 Samuel 10 initiates the kingship theme that ultimately points to the Messiah Yeshua. The establishment of human kingship in Israel, despite its flawed beginnings, sets the stage for the Davidic covenant and the eventual coming of the perfect King who would fulfill all of God’s promises to His people.
Ancient Key Word Study
- Anointed (וַיִּצֹ֥ק – vayitzok): The Hebrew word literally means “to pour out,” suggesting a lavish, generous application of oil. This ritual act symbolized the conferral of divine authority and the Spirit’s empowerment for leadership. The same root is used in reference to the Messiah (מָשִׁיחַ – Mashiach), highlighting the prophetic significance of this act.
- Flask (פַּ֥ךְ – pach): This specific term refers to a small vessel, typically used for sacred purposes. Its use here emphasizes the holy nature of the anointing oil and the ceremonial significance of the moment. Unlike larger containers used for common purposes, this flask was reserved for sacred use.
- Spirit of יהוה (רוּחַ־יְהוָה – Ruach Yahweh): This phrase denotes divine empowerment for leadership. The sudden coming of the Spirit upon Saul represents divine enablement for his royal task, though notably temporary in his case, unlike David’s later permanent anointing.
- Changed (נֶהְפַּ֥ךְ – nehpach): This word implies a complete transformation or turning into something else. It’s used to describe Saul’s spiritual transformation, suggesting a fundamental change in his character and capabilities through divine intervention.
- Prophesy (הִתְנַבֵּ֖א – hitnabe): In this context, the word describes ecstatic prophetic behavior rather than predictive prophecy. It signifies being overwhelmed by the Spirit’s presence, resulting in visible manifestations of spiritual activity.
- Signs (אֹת֔וֹת – otot): These divine confirmations served as supernatural validation of Saul’s anointing. The word specifically denotes events that authenticate a divine commission or message.
- Another Heart (לֵ֣ב אַחֵ֑ר – lev acher): This phrase suggests a fundamental transformation of character and perspective, indicating divine preparation for leadership. It implies more than emotional change, but a complete reorientation of one’s inner being.
- Lot (גּוֹרָל – goral): The method used for Saul’s public selection reflects ancient practices of discerning divine will. This term emphasizes the sovereign control of יהוה in the selection process.
- Hide (נֶחְבָּ֥א – nechba): Saul’s hiding among the baggage uses a word that can also mean “to withdraw.” This choice of vocabulary provides insight into his character and initial humility.
Compare & Contrast
- Verse 1’s use of “flask” (פַּ֥ךְ – pach) rather than “horn” (קֶרֶן – keren) is significant. When Samuel later anoints David, he uses a horn of oil (1 Samuel 16:13), suggesting a more permanent and robust anointing. The flask’s fragility may symbolize the temporary nature of Saul’s kingship.
- The phrase “another heart” in verse 9 employs “אַחֵ֑ר” (acher) rather than “חָדָשׁ” (chadash – new). This choice emphasizes transformation rather than creation, possibly indicating that while Saul was changed, he wasn’t given the kind of fundamental renewal later described in prophetic texts about the Messiah’s reign.
- Verse 6’s prophecy of the Spirit “rushing” (צָלַח – tzalach) upon Saul contrasts with later descriptions of the Spirit’s work. This term suggests a temporary empowerment rather than the permanent indwelling promised in the New Covenant (Ezekiel 36:27).
- The description of Saul hiding among the baggage uses “נֶחְבָּ֥א” (nechba) rather than “הִסְתַתֵּר” (histater), suggesting a more passive withdrawal rather than active concealment, perhaps hinting at his character’s future weaknesses.
- The public selection process through lots emphasizes divine sovereignty using “גּוֹרָל” (goral) rather than human choice terms, highlighting that despite Israel’s demand for a king, יהוה remained in control of the process.
1 Samuel 10 Unique Insights
The chapter contains several layers of prophetic and theological significance that might not be immediately apparent to modern readers. The three signs given to Saul mirror significant moments in Israel’s history: the meeting at Rachel’s tomb recalls Israel’s maternal origins, the encounter at the oak of Tabor echoes patriarchal worship, and the prophetic experience at Gibeah reflects Moses’ sharing of the Spirit with the seventy elders.
Ancient Jewish commentary notes that Saul’s encounter with the prophets at Gibeah represented a unique moment in Israel’s spiritual history. The Targum Jonathan suggests that the prophets were reciting the creation account and the future coming of the Messiah, indicating that even this momentary spiritual experience contained elements pointing to יהוה’s ultimate plan for redemption through the true King.
The seemingly peculiar detail of Saul hiding among the baggage carries deeper significance in light of rabbinic interpretation. The Hebrew word for “baggage” (כֵּלִים – kelim) is the same word used for temple vessels, possibly suggesting that Saul’s positioning foreshadowed how the monarchy would relate to the priesthood – sometimes hidden, sometimes revealed, but always meant to work in harmony with sacred things.
The chapter also presents an interesting tension between divine sovereignty and human free will. While יהוה clearly orchestrates Saul’s anointing through supernatural signs and the lot-casting process, He also allows for human response and responsibility. This dynamic would characterize the entire monarchy period and points forward to the perfect balance achieved in Messiah Yeshua’s kingship.
1 Samuel 10 Connections to Yeshua
The anointing of Saul provides several significant types and shadows that point to the Messiah Yeshua. While Saul’s anointing was with a temporary flask, Yeshua’s anointing was eternal, as prophesied in Psalm 45:7, “Therefore God, your God, has anointed you with the oil of gladness beyond your companions.” The temporary nature of Saul’s spiritual empowerment contrasts with the permanent anointing of the Messiah who possesses the Spirit without measure (John 3:34).
The transformation of Saul’s heart foreshadows the greater heart transformation that Yeshua brings through the New Covenant. While Saul received “another heart,” Messiah gives His people a “new heart” (Ezekiel 36:26). This contrast highlights the superiority of Messiah’s kingdom, where the Spirit’s work is not just external empowerment but internal transformation.
1 Samuel 10 Scriptural Echoes
The anointing ceremony in this chapter resonates with numerous biblical passages. It anticipates David’s anointing in 1 Samuel 16 and finds ultimate fulfillment in Yeshua’s anointing described in Isaiah 61:1. The Spirit’s empowerment of Saul echoes the experience of the seventy elders (Numbers 11:25) and anticipates the outpouring of the Spirit at Pentecost (Acts 2).
The theme of divine kingship established here continues throughout Scripture, finding its climax in Yeshua’s eternal reign. The tension between human and divine kingship introduced in this chapter is resolved only in the Messiah, who perfectly embodies both human and divine authority.
1 Samuel 10 Devotional
This chapter challenges us to examine our own response to God’s calling and anointing in our lives. Like Saul, we may feel inadequate or even attempt to hide from God’s purposes, but His sovereign choice and empowerment remain sure. The question is not whether we are naturally qualified, but whether we will submit to His transforming work in our lives.
The supernatural signs given to Saul remind us that God often confirms His calling through multiple witnesses and experiences. However, these confirmations require our faithful response. We must step out in faith, trusting not in our own abilities but in His empowerment through the Spirit.
Consider how God has “changed your heart” and given you His Spirit. Unlike Saul’s temporary experience, believers in Yeshua have received a permanent indwelling of the Spirit. How are you stewarding this gift? Are you allowing the Spirit to transform you and empower you for service in God’s kingdom?
Did You Know
- The location where Samuel anointed Saul, Ramah, was a significant prophetic center in ancient Israel, known for its school of prophets and its role in preserving true worship during spiritually declining periods.
- The practice of anointing with oil was not unique to Israel but took on special significance in the biblical context, symbolizing both practical preparation for service and spiritual empowerment.
- The prophetic bands mentioned in this chapter were likely formal schools where young prophets were trained in the law, music, and the prophetic traditions of Israel.
- The phrase “Is Saul also among the prophets?” became a proverbial expression in ancient Israel, used to describe unexpected spiritual sensitivity in unlikely individuals.
- The baggage among which Saul hid likely referred to the military and ceremonial equipment brought by the tribal representatives to the assembly.
- The three signs given to Saul formed a geographical triangle that encompassed significant portions of Benjamin’s tribal territory, symbolically representing his future realm of authority.
- Ancient Jewish tradition suggests that the scroll the prophets were studying when Saul encountered them contained portions of what would become the Torah, particularly the creation account and early prophecies about the Messiah.
- The lot-casting ceremony described in the chapter used a specific method called “going down” through successive divisions, demonstrating sophisticated ancient practices for discerning divine will.
- Samuel’s decision to write the “rights and duties of kingship” in a book and place it before יהוה represented the first constitutional monarchy in recorded history.