The F.O.G Commentary:
What is the meaning of 1 Samuel 1?
Introduction to 1 Samuel 1
The opening chapter of 1 Samuel marks a pivotal transition in Israel’s history, bridging the period of the Judges to the monarchy. This narrative introduces us to Hannah, whose profound struggle with infertility and subsequent faithful prayer becomes the catalyst for the emergence of Samuel, one of Israel’s greatest prophets. The chapter masterfully weaves together themes of personal anguish, divine intervention, and sacrificial dedication, setting the stage for God’s sovereign plan to establish kingship in Israel.
Context of 1 Samuel 1
The book of 1 Samuel opens during a dark period in Israel’s history, as described in the final chapters of Judges where “everyone did what was right in their own eyes” (Judges 21:25). The corruption of the priesthood under Eli and his sons at Shiloh represents the spiritual decay of the nation. This chapter serves as a bridge between the chaotic period of the Judges and the establishment of the monarchy.
The larger biblical narrative positions this chapter as a crucial turning point, echoing earlier barren-to-blessed mother narratives like Sarah and Rachel. Hannah’s story particularly parallels that of Sarah, as both women’s supernatural conceptions resulted in sons who would play transformative roles in Israel’s history. This chapter also establishes themes that will resonate throughout Samuel’s books: the power of prayer, God’s sovereignty in raising up leaders, and the contrast between genuine and superficial worship.
Ancient Key Word Study
- חַנָּה (Hannah) – Derived from the Hebrew root meaning “grace” or “favor.” Her name becomes prophetic of her story, as she receives divine favor through answered prayer. The name’s etymology connects to the concept of unmerited divine favor, a theme that runs throughout Scripture.
- שִׁלֹה (Shiloh) – The central sanctuary where the Ark of the Covenant resided. The word possibly derives from שָׁלָה (shalah), meaning “to be at rest/ease.” This location represented God’s dwelling place among His people, making Hannah’s prayer there particularly significant.
- פְּנִנָּה (Peninnah) – Name meaning “coral” or “pearl.” The contrast between her fertility and Hannah’s barrenness creates the narrative tension. Her role as the “fertile antagonist” parallels Hagar in Sarah’s story.
- צְבָאוֹת (Tseva’ot) – “Hosts” or “armies,” used in the divine title “LORD of Hosts.” This military title emphasizes God’s sovereign power over all forces, earthly and heavenly, making Hannah’s use of it particularly poignant in her prayer.
- נָזִיר (Nazir) – “Dedicated” or “consecrated one.” Hannah’s vow to make Samuel a Nazirite represented the highest form of dedication to God’s service, paralleling Samson’s consecration.
- שָׁאַל (Sha’al) – “To ask” or “request.” This root forms a wordplay with Samuel’s name (שְׁמוּאֵל), as he was the one “asked of God.” This etymology becomes significant in understanding Samuel’s role as an intercessor.
- מָרַת נָפֶשׁ (Marat Nephesh) – “Bitter of soul.” This phrase describes Hannah’s deep anguish, using imagery that would later be echoed in Ruth’s Naomi and Job’s laments.
Compare & Contrast
- Verse 3’s mention of “yearly sacrifice” (זֶבַח הַיָּמִים) could have used the more common term מוֹעֵד (mo’ed) for appointed times. The chosen phrase emphasizes the regularity and familial nature of the pilgrimage, rather than its official status as a required feast.
- In verse 11, Hannah’s vow uses the intense form “if You will indeed look” (רָאֹה תִרְאֶה), employing a Hebrew infinitive absolute construction. This grammatical choice emphasizes the depth of her plea compared to a simple “if You look.”
- The description of Eli sitting on his seat by the doorpost (verse 9) uses כִּסֵּא (kisse) rather than מוֹשָׁב (moshav), suggesting official authority rather than mere resting, foreshadowing his role in authenticating Hannah’s vow.
- Hannah’s reference to herself as God’s “maidservant” (אָמָה) in verse 11 rather than the more common שִׁפְחָה (shifchah) suggests a closer, more intimate relationship with God, similar to Mary’s later self-description in Luke 1:38.
- The phrase “in process of time” (verse 20) uses לִתְקֻפוֹת הַיָּמִים rather than the simpler בְּאַחֲרִית הַיָּמִים, emphasizing the cyclical nature of time and pregnancy rather than mere chronological progression.
1 Samuel 1 Unique Insights
The chapter contains several layers of meaning that point to divine patterns in Scripture. Hannah’s prayer at the sanctuary introduces a new paradigm of personal prayer in Israel’s worship. Unlike earlier biblical prayers, hers is silent yet intense, establishing a model of heart-focused rather than merely ritualistic prayer that would later be emphasized by the prophets and Yeshua Himself.
The Rabbinical tradition in Talmud Berachot 31b draws profound lessons from Hannah’s prayer, noting that her lips moving without sound became the basis for the Jewish practice of silent prayer. This tradition sees Hannah as establishing nine fundamental principles of prayer, including the need for clear articulation (even if silent), proper focus, and the importance of standing before God.
The parallel between Hannah and Sarah extends beyond their barrenness to their roles in divine transition periods. Just as Sarah’s son Isaac represented the transition from patriarchal promise to tribal formation, Hannah’s son Samuel represents the transition from tribal confederation to monarchy. Both women’s stories emphasize God’s pattern of using the unlikely and overlooked to accomplish His purposes.
The timing of Samuel’s birth and dedication also carries prophetic significance. According to early Jewish chronologies, his birth coincided with the period when the Ark resided in Shiloh, just before its capture by the Philistines. This timing positioned Samuel to be the prophet who would guide Israel through the loss and eventual restoration of proper worship, paralleling how Yeshua would later guide His people through the transition from Temple-centered to Spirit-centered worship.
1 Samuel 1 Connections to Yeshua
Hannah’s song in the following chapter prefigures Mary’s Magnificat, establishing a pattern of God’s kingdom breaking into history through the prayers of faithful women and miraculous births. Both Hannah and Mary recognize their children as divine gifts who would transform Israel’s worship and leadership.
The dedication of Samuel as a Nazirite from birth foreshadows aspects of Yeshua’s dedication to His Father’s service. While Yeshua was not a Nazirite, the concept of complete dedication from birth establishes a pattern that finds its ultimate fulfillment in Him. Samuel’s role as prophet, priest, and judge points to Yeshua’s threefold office of Prophet, Priest, and King.
1 Samuel 1 Scriptural Echoes
The chapter resonates with numerous biblical narratives and themes:
- The barren-to-blessed mother motif connects to Sarah (Genesis 16), Rebecca (Genesis 25:21), and Rachel (Genesis 30).
- Hannah’s vow parallels Jephthah’s vow (Judges 11:30-31) but with a more positive outcome.
- The theme of dedication from birth connects to Samson (Judges 13) and John the Baptist (Luke 1:15).
- The corrupt priesthood under Eli foreshadows the religious leadership during Yeshua’s time.
1 Samuel 1 Devotional
This chapter speaks powerfully to those experiencing seasons of waiting and apparent divine silence. Hannah’s story reminds us that our deepest anguish can become the seedbed for God’s greatest works. Her example teaches us several vital spiritual principles:
First, she brought her raw emotions honestly before God. Rather than hiding her pain or pretending to be fine, she poured out her heart in authentic prayer. This challenges us to bring our genuine feelings to God, trusting His compassion and understanding.
Second, Hannah’s vow demonstrates the principle of open-handed dedication. Unlike Jephthah’s rash vow, her promise to dedicate Samuel to God’s service flowed from a heart of gratitude and worship. This challenges us to hold our blessings with open hands, recognizing everything as a gift from God to be used for His purposes.
Finally, Hannah’s faithfulness in fulfilling her vow, even when it meant giving up her long-awaited son, demonstrates the kind of trust that God honors. Her story encourages us to trust God’s larger purposes, even when they require personal sacrifice.
Did You Know
- The phrase “year by year” in verse 7 uses the Hebrew הַיָּמִים (hayamim), literally “the days,” reflecting an ancient Hebrew way of marking time by days rather than years.
- The portion of meat given to Hannah in verse 5 is described as אַפָּיִם, literally “two faces” or “double portion,” a term that appears only here in the Bible in this context.
- The name “Elkanah” means “God has created/possessed,” possibly indicating his family’s devotion to יהוה despite the corrupt religious environment.
- The phrase “evil eye” used to describe Peninnah’s treatment of Hannah is a Hebrew idiom for jealousy and malicious behavior, still used in Middle Eastern cultures today.
- The term used for “drunk” when Eli accuses Hannah is שִׁכֹּרָה (shikkorah), related to the word for “strong drink” (שֵׁכָר, shekar), distinct from wine.
- Hannah’s prayer contains the first biblical use of the title “LORD of Hosts” (יהוה צְבָאוֹת) by an individual, previously used only in formal religious contexts.
- The three bulls mentioned in verse 24 as Hannah’s offering represent an extremely generous sacrifice, indicating both gratitude and wealth.
- The linen ephod Samuel wore (verse 18) was typically reserved for priests, making his wearing of it as a child particularly significant.
- The name “Samuel” creates a wordplay in Hebrew between “asked of God” (שָׁאוּל מֵאֵל) and “heard by God” (שָׁמַע אֵל), reflecting both Hannah’s request and God’s response.